There are no more persistent problems in schools than the constant attempt to place modern morals on ancient cultures.
Yes, slavery is terrible by today’s morals – but EVERY civilization for many thousands of years practiced it and we marvel at the work that slaves did, but some attack American slave-owners. Some even take that opportunity to attack great men like Washington and Jefferson for their slaves but that again places today’s mores on a time when the morals were vastly different. (Even in the late 1700s, slavery was accepted although things were beginning to change.)
It is de rigueur among liberals to attack America for its use of the atomic bomb in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, but the world was in the grasp of a terrible war that had lasted years and killed millions of people. No one who was not alive then can appreciate the need for the use of those terrible weapons.
Someday, the Second-Guessers will look back at something that we accept as “normal” much as it is easy to condemn cigarette smokers today. But smoking was “normal” (actually fashionable) just 25 years ago. Had you been alive in 1690 in New York City, and certainly if you had lived in Atlanta, it is likely you would have accepted slavery.
If you had been a Marine Corporal sitting on Okinawa in 1945, do you think you would have oppose “Fat Boy?” Unlikely. Suppose you had been the Corporal’s mother in Cincinnati?
By the end of your life, you will see many changes from normal and accepted, to quaint, to “how could they,” to immoral. You may find that something you do today without thinking (because it is an accepted norm), has become immoral by the time you are 75. Perhaps it will be eating meat, or using a private automobile, or getting married, or …
Future mores are not predictable. Assessing how you might have behaved 50 or 100 or 500 years ago is arrogance.
Filed under: Uncategorized | Leave a comment »