As someone who has been summoned to the study of a local Rabbi, and denounced from the pulpit of a Rancho Bernardo temple, I can feel a (very small) bit of sympathy for Helen Thomas – except that she was dead wrong. Not just inarticulate. Wrong.
Can you imagine telling the Blacks they should go back to Africa?
That is the type of comment that Helen made. It was unforgivable. It was wrong. Her remarks reflect what is common in the leftist college campus discussions.
My “sin” was to write a column that said I loved Israel just as I love my own children – but that I did not believe in supporting either Israel or my children after 21 years!
The only nice thing that the speaker in the Temple said about me that I appreciated was, “We all know him. He is not anti-Semitic. He is simply wrong.”
But Helen Thomas has always been a supporter of Palestine (whatever that is), and has always hated Israel. Her line of questioning at the White House has shown that for many years. She is not just a liberal, she is a leftist and a pro-Hamas leftist at that.
She finally said that which we all knew she believed.
I have not clearly understood the Jew’s need for a “homeland” – certainly not all of them, and those who do have varying levels of “need.”
I reflexively come down on the side of Israel.
I wrote on this Blog, regarding the attempt to pierce the blockade “Mess with the bull, you get the horns.”
I hate stupid people, and as the young “peace activist” who was killed a few years ago by an Israeli bulldozer found out — when you step in front of a bulldozer, driven by a Jew or an Arab — you die! I served in a submarine service that could not abide stupidity because it caused not only the stupid’s death but the death of everyone on the boat.
All Purple Hearts on submarines are awarded posthumously.
Sorry, I can’t muster a lot of sympathy.
As I understand this story — the first four soldiers were lured aboard from a rubber boat by promises of non-resistance, set upon, knifed and hustled belowdecks. It was only then that the action started. If I had been the leader and four of my men had been captured I would have opened fire also with a great deal less restraint.
As Helen Thomas has recently shown, there is a visceral hatred for Israel among many of the liberal elite — hers has been apparent for more than a decade.
I have published my concern with using the Bible as justification to found a state (whatever happened to the separation), and my unwillingness to continue sending foreign aide the Israel — but they ARE a state (regardless of their founding, just as we are a state regardless of our treatment of the Indians), and they deserve to be left in peace.
That is not what is going on. They are under siege.
I heard an explanation (certainly just one explanation) for liberals supporting the Palestinians: That liberals always support the underdog. In this case there are two underdogs — and I come down on the side of the Israelis — not necessarily because they are Jews (although that is as good a reason as any), but because they are smart.
I am just writing a lengthy review (13 pages and growing) of the liberal, (and largely Jewish) infatuation with Communism and espionage against the US in the 20s,30s,40s and 50s — based on several books VERY recently published (Yale University Press) with new information on recently disclosed (1995) code-breaking and CPUSA/Comintern documents released in Russia. In that review it became apparent to me that ONE of the reasons for Jewish participation in acts for Russia was the longing of the Jews for a homeland, and Stalin gave them one in an area of Siberia. The story of George Koval — only admitted in 2007 when Putin gave him Russia’s highest medal, was an important milestone in my knowledge base.
That apparent homeland-longing for some Jews, combined with real racism against them is something I had probably understood intellectually, but had not understood viscerally.
I am only starting to get it now.
Filed under: Culture, International Events, Media, Military, Politics, Taxes, World Events | Leave a comment »