General McChrystal was, as are most warriors, impolitic — but Boy Scouts don’t win wars.
There is a vast difference between peace-time officers and war-time officers – peacetime officers get medals for umpiring Little League games and collecting money for the United Crusade. In wartime, we want men who can man the pass against the Huns, and that is a different breed who get in bar fights and don’t pay their bills. They make lousy neighbors in a tidy homeowners association – but they can crawl through broken glass to silently cut a throat.
In an all-out war, the General would have been forgiven without so much as a note. In peacetime, he would have been cashiered. We are neither at war, nor in peace — so no rules are the order of the day.
If insubordination was strictly enforced, our military would consist of a rotating Honor Guard, a single-engine plane, and a row-boat. Anyone who has ever served any amount of time has been in bull-sessions that would curl a president’s hair — any president of any political party.
There was a time (I remember it) when military officers did not register to vote, because voting for anyone but the existing president would show disrespect and “insubordination.”
Obviously, those days are long gone.
From a political standpoint, I find that firing a liberal, political supporter of the president — and replacing him with a General previously denounced by the left for his views is surreal.
It is all political theater — and it only makes a difference what the troops think. McChrystal is a known GREAT warrior, the kind men die for — his replacement is a great planner and politician. What the troops think, matters. It matters a great deal — and I have no clue.
Patton, BTW, like Douglas MacArthur, got in trouble not for this kind of BS, but for challenging the nation’s policy – Patton wanted to continue to Moscow, and MacArthur into North Korea. Neither got in trouble for what can only be described a “grousing,” as did McChrystal.
Fortunately, we are blessed with a surfeit of fine Generals.
It is much like the don’t Ask, Don’t Tell. What you and I think makes no nevermind. It is what the kid walking into the recruiting station in Tennessee the month after the policy is abolished thinks that counts — and neither you nor I have a clue.
In the current less-than-war atmosphere, any president can replace any General with impunity, if the president has particularly thin skin – or wants to make a political statement. President Obama just had a General Alexander Haig moment. (“I am in charge here.”)
It is what the warriors think that count.
Leadership cannot be appointed.
(It can’t be elected, either.)
Filed under: Culture, Justice, Military, Politics | Leave a comment »